Showing posts with label Herman Cain. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Herman Cain. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 8, 2011

GOP Candidate Economic Plans and Income Inequality

Rick Perry's alternative 20% tax plan came out the same week as the Congressional Budget Office report "Trends in the Distribution of Household Income Between 1979 and 2007".

Of the three current top polling candidates, Cain's 9-9-9 plan does the most to accelerate income inequality. Mitt Romney was criticized by Newt Gingrich for capping capital gains tax exemptions. He responded that the middle-class has had a tough go of things under Barack Obama.

Inequality Chat

Paul Solmon, who I remember entertainingly explained the role arbitrage played in the 1987 Black Friday stock fall, followed his PBS NewsHour series with a Twitter chat on 10/28/11, which is re-organized and somewhat translated into English below. I apologize for deleting comments that Solman did not address but it was helpful for the sake of a coherent Q&A.

Without getting into arguments about whether or not the United States Government taxes too much or spends too little, this independent voter is primarily interested in two issues. How does income inequality affect the ability of the private sector to function?

Question: Why a series on economy inequality?
Solman: I think it's the most important economic issue of our time, has been for years. Can America Dream, US survive inequality like Gilded Age, '20s?

JRRuss67: What happened in mid-70s to cause the gap to widen so much?
Solman: Lots: Globalization (cheap labor) I. Deregulation. Diminished influence of unions. Big boost came from '80s with "tax reform."

Question: Why feature Libertarian Epstein? Don't they get enough air time?
Solman: Maybe, but not from us. I thought he made his case so blatantly, viewers could evaluate it for themselves. Disagree?

tniblett: How have we convinced ourselves that inequality is good for USA?
Solman: Because it's in the interest of the economy's winners to champion the notion that they deserve what they get?

tniblett: True, but why is it in the interest of economy's losers to believe it?
Solman: A puzzle why economy losers believe it. But polls now suggest we increasingly DON'T believe inequality is good for economy.

Question: Doesn't inequality always contribute to inequality or repression?
Solman: No, inequality doesn't ALWAYS contribute to political instability or repression. But it doesn't seem help either one & if wide enough.

tkmalone: How does concentrated wealth affect consumer spending? More money on fewer individual needs, food, houses, cars, etc.?
Solman: Concentrated wealth hurts consumer spending because wealthy save a higher percentage of their income. Much higher.

Question: Why not "income disparity" instead of "inequality," which implies something wrong, INequitable?
Solman: Because "inequality" is a clear and true description? Would you prefer "income asymmetry"? Folks would feel even better.

Question: It seems the corporations have written off consumer demand and are still making profits?
Solman: US corps are selling more and more abroad. That's presumably why the US market has gyrated so because of events in Europe, China.

norrisj: 12th grade economy class here. We are concerned about equal opportunity vs. equal result.
Solman: "Equal opportunity" sounds great. But if only some folks have marketable skills in this economy and others don't, then what? Can those of us with skills that aren't "marketable" opt out of this market in ignorance, deceit and obedience? Aside from unemployment? The grim truth is, choices are to opt out via downshifting (living with folks? At Zucotti Park?) or getting the skills. Opportunity inequality based on marketable ability. Needs to be role for folks with limited ability, be it factory or massage.

policylink: How do the coming racial demographic changes play into this debate? US will be majority people of color by 2042
Solman: I don't know. You'd think poorer minorities would vote for equality policies, wouldn't you?

AFWorkforce: People need choice. Many people feel like they are looking at glass ceiling and shackled to job
Solman: Yes, hard to move if you can't sell your house or are terrified that if you quit your job, you won't find another.

BerylSchewe: How do we widen the chances for equal opportunity without increasing entitlements?
Solman: Why "entitlements"? How about real jobs that need doing, done by sidelined Americans? CCC anyone?

norrisj: What would you propose for equality policy? Income cap? Tax the rich? confiscate?
Solman: Taxing the wealthy seems such an obvious starting point. Top tax rate under Wilson: 77%; FDR: 94%. Today: 35%!

mediacodex From London: Isn't raising opportunities for lower classes more important a focus than on lower inequality?
Solman: Yes, focus on job opportunities for the low downs but can it be done without investing in them? Who will invest but high ups?

bwmcr: How do we begin to showcase that economic policies that increase equality are not socialist, and gaining acceptance.
Solman: FDR was accused of being a socialist and, compared to what had preceded him, perhaps he was.

DgwilsonDave: What about putting fees on fossil fuels and emissions and rebating equally per person?
Solman: Charging the true cost of negative externalities like pollution is basic economics. But wouldn't do much to affect inequality.

bwmcr: How about tax breaks for companies that have more equal pay like Ben and Jerry's? Reward socially-mindedness.
Solman: It would be very difficult to legislate. Got to be easier to tax the wealthy. And if government owns, to pay top dogs less.

tsheely67 Why does such a high percent pay NO federal tax? Wouldn't more stakeholders insist on less waste?
Solman: Interesting point. Flat taxers say simple is better. But you can have simple and progressive both. Check out original tax form.

JohnMesserly: Paul, recall when you did your first story on it?
Solman: For PBS Boston, inequality stories in early '80s. For NewsHour, "Upstairs, Downstairs" in '87. Reported "Hourglass economics" in '89.

Sunday, October 16, 2011

The Man Behind Cain's 9-9-9 Plan

During the 10/12/11 GOP debate on the economy, when Herman Cain was asked who he turned to for political advice, he replied, "One of my experts that helped me to develop this was a gentleman by the name of Rich Lowrie out of Cleveland, Ohio. He is an economist and he has worked in the business of wealth creation most of his career."

What kind of economist is Rich Lowrie?


According to his Linkedin page he has a BS in Accountancy from Case Western Reserve University.

How did Rich Lowrie create wealth?

He is currently a wealth management adviser at the Pepper Pike, Ohio branch of Wells Fargo.

"We offer comprehensive wealth management solutions for business owners, executives, professionals, families and fiduciaries."

Is a background in economics important?


Here's an exchange from the debate.

JULIANA GOLDMAN (Bloomberg TV): Mr. Cain, you say that your plan is revenue-neutral. And last year, the U.S. collected $2.2 trillion dollars in tax revenue, but Bloomberg Government has run the numbers, and your plan would have raised no more than $2 trillion. And even with that shortfall, you'd still be slapping a 9 percent sales tax on food and medicine.

CAIN: The problem with that analysis is that it is incorrect. The reason it is incorrect is because they start with the assumptions that we don't make. Remember, 9-9-9 plan throws out the current tax code.

Cain uses this statement as a means of getting back to his talking points. I don't believe that Bloomberg Government would "forget" that 9-9-9 throws out the current tax code because analyzing the alternative tax code was the purpose of their calculation.

CAIN: We have had an outside firm, independent firm dynamically score it. And so our numbers will make it revenue neutral.

Now we have a comparison of one named independent firm Bloomberg Government using existing numbers to evaluate Herman Cain's "simple, transparent, efficient, fair, and neutral" plan refuted by an unnamed independent firm's "dynamic scoring." Dynamic scoring is not an accounting principle but an economic one.

GOLDMAN: But then explain why under your plan all Americans should be paying more for milk, for a loaf of bread, and beer?

CAIN: You have to start with the biggest tax cut a lot of Americans pay, which is the payroll tax, 15.3 percent. That goes to 9 percent. That is a 6 percentage point difference. And the prices will not go up. So they have got a 6 percentage point difference to apply to the national sales tax piece of that, and in doing so, they have the flexibility to decide on how much they want to spend it on new goods, how much they want to spend it on used goods. Because there is no tax on used goods.

Here we get a look at Cain's assumptions.

Fact: Americans who pay only a payroll tax will have 6.3 percent more cash in their pocket to pay the new 9 percent sales tax.

Assumption: Prices will never go up.

Assumption: Purchasing used goods will mitigate any net tax increase from the new 9 percent tax.

Here is another fact not questioned during the debate about categories of income exempted from the 9 percent tax.

Fact: Taxes for capital gains and dividends and the estate tax go away completely.

For an independent voter it is often as important to know who advocates a proposal as the nuts and bolts of the proposal itself.

In terms of 9-9-9, how would a wealth management advisor and his clients fare under the new tax code?

Monday, October 10, 2011

Herman Cain's 9-9-9: Shifting the Tax Burden from Producers to Consumers and Suggestions for How the Poor Can Pay the Higher Taxes

Herman Cain's Message

If you visit HermanCain.com, Kent Short, an American butcher, has some glowing words for his candidate of choice. "When they asked him a question, he was just very up front and honest and says, 'I can't give you an answer because I don't know what all the facts are. And that's what we're doin' wrong.' People were giving answers without facts. And as soon as I heard him say that, I said, this is the only guy who's got any sense in the whole thing."

Herman Cain won the Florida Straw Poll with this message.



He begins with a subtle dig at his fellow candidate speakers by asking, "whose teleprompters are these? I'm not using them." It's true. He has lots of experience as a motivational speaker and radio talk show host.

"It must be borne in mind that the tragedy of life does not lie in not reaching your goals, the tragedy lies in having no goals to reach for. It is not a calamity to die with dreams unfulfilled, but it is a calamity to have no dreams." an unattributed quote from Benjamin E. Mays, who was President of Morehouse College when Cain graduated from there with a B.S. in 1967.

He lists the crises that America faces and offers the good news that we can solve these crises by identifying and hitting the target called "fix it", a reference to his days as a ballistic analyst "working for the Department of the Navy." This is not to be confused with Cain serving in the Navy. He did not.

When he states his bold solution to fix the economy, the audience chants in unison: "9-9-9." But for the independent voter, what exactly is 9-9-9?

Throw out all of the current tax code. Impose a 9 percent business flat tax, a 9 percent personal income tax, and a 9 percent national sales tax. It would be revenue neutral. It replaces all corporate and personal income taxes, capital gains, estate taxes, payroll tax. It provides certainty to the engine of economic growth: the business sector.

Energy: "America is going to dig here, drill here, and explore here first…we have the resources to become energy independent."

Restructuring Social Security: "Seniors don't worry. You won't be affected. Near retirement seniors. You don't have to worry. Because a personal retirement accounts option for younger workers will allow us over time to take care of those where promises were made." Younger workers would have an option to establish their own accounts.

National Security: "Peace through strength and clarity." We would "clearly identify who our friends are, clearly identify who our enemies are, and stop giving money to the enemies." When it comes to defense, he wouldn't look for what to cut but what to enhance. "If we are not in it to win it, we will not be in it."

The Founding Fathers: "'When any form of government becomes destructive of those ideals' (all men are created equal with unalienable rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness 'it is the right of the people to alter or abolish it.' We've got some altering and abolishing to do." Here he cites not the Constitution, which he would have to swear to protect and defend, but the Declaration of Independence, a document to spell out our grievances against King George III.

He ends with an appeal to "help me to push that shining city on a hill back to the top of the hill. Vote Cain in 2012."

9-9-9 Analysis:

On 09/30/11, the Christian Science Monitor took a look at 9-9-9 in Herman Cain's '999 plan': long overdue tax reform or job killer?" Some highlights:

9 Percent National Sales Tax

Rich Lowrie, Cain’s senior economic advisor claims it would shift the tax burden from production to consumption, allowing exporters to pay less tax on goods they produce and impose a 9% tax on imported goods.

Possible implications of the national sales tax included a negative impact on consumer demand and the possibility of retailers cheating by offering a lower price for wink, wink cash purchases.

9 Percent Corporate Tax

The possible implication of eliminating the business deduction for labor but not investment was favoring heavy industry over the service sector, such as Cain's former business: Godfather's Pizza.

Overall Tax Burden

Using an economic measure called "marginal propensity to consume" (necessary to evaluate the impact of a national sales tax), the article estimated that those who earned:

$20,000 would pay 17 percent vs. the current 12.8 percent.
$55,000 would pay 17.95 percent vs. the current 16.9 percent.
$300,000 would pay 16.3 percent vs. the 27.97 percent.

When asked about this disparity and the regressive nature of sales tax by Chris Wallace on the 10/02/11 Fox News Sunday, Cain responded with a figure for a $50,000 income earner that worked out in his favor according to his plan but without taking into account deductions allowed under the current tax code. Perhaps he should have stuck to "I can't give you an answer because I don't know what all the facts are."

Another concern voiced in the article was the impact shifting to a consumption tax would have on senior citizens who would face the new 9% sales tax on the way to a 30% national sales "fair tax" (a total shift away from income taxation) while the payroll tax supporting Social Security was eliminated.

For criteria on deciding whether independent voters should consider this "fair share" or "class warfare" see Barack Obama's Balanced Approach: Fair Share or Class Warfare?

Impact on Deficit

Chief Economist at Moody's Analytics Mark Zandi opines that the 9-9-9 plan is revenue neutral at the current rate of federal income: 15% of GDP.

The country currently spends 24% of GDP. The last time the budget was balanced was at 19.5% of GDP with $496 billion more in revenue than it collects today.



For more independent voter's perspective on the path to a balanced budget, see Balanced Budget Amendment

Poor People

On the 10/09/11 edition of Face the Nation, Bob Schieffer asked Cain about the provision that exempted used goods from the 9 percent national sales tax (I couldn't find this on hermaincain.com).

Schieffer: "Aren't poor people also going to get to pay a tax on food and a tax on medicine?"

Cain: "You give poor people more opportunity to stretch their dollar and leverage their income based upon their decision whether to buy new or used goods."

I can't help it but the option of poor people buying used food brought to mind a variation on a famous quote by Marie-Thérèse, the wife of Louis XIV, often falsely attributed to Marie Antoinette.

"Let them eat _ _ _ _. "